In brief
- On 19 November 2026, Advocate General Laila Medina delivered her Opinion in Case C-643/25 before the Court of Justice of the EU.
- She proposes that providing personal data and consenting to its commercial use is a form of payment under Directive 2005/29/EC, so the service cannot be described as 'free'.
- The Opinion is not binding; the Court will rule at a later date.
Advocate General Laila Medina has proposed that the Court of Justice of the European Union rule that a service cannot be advertised as « free » when users pay with their data. Her Opinion in Case C-643/25, delivered on 19 November 2026, bears directly on business models funded by personalised advertising.
Background to the case
In February 2015, the registration page of Facebook, operated in the Union by Meta Platforms Ireland, stated that the network « is and remains free ». The Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband (the German federation of consumer organisations) challenged that wording, arguing that users hand over their data and consent to its commercial use in exchange for access. The German courts dismissed the action, reasoning that the prohibition applies only where consumers bear financial costs. The Bundesgerichtshof (German Federal Court of Justice) then referred the matter to the Court of Justice.
What the Advocate General proposes
Medina suggests that disclosing personal data and consenting to its commercial use is a form of payment under Directive 2005/29/EC on unfair commercial practices. A service requiring such data could therefore not be called free, unless the data are processed solely to provide the service or to meet legal obligations.
Her main reasons:
- The directive does not confine payment to money; the Court has already accepted other forms of consideration with economic value and a definite link to the practice.
- Data and consent have economic value for the operator, since they generate the advertising revenue that funds the service.
- Directive (EU) 2019/770 and Directive 2011/83/EU already recognise digital services supplied in exchange for data. It would be inconsistent to accept that there and allow them to be presented as free here.
- Limiting payment to money would weaken consumer protection, as users are often unaware of the value of their data.
Meta’s arguments rejected
In the Advocate General’s view, only the legislature can change the list of practices prohibited in all circumstances, but that does not require its terms to be read narrowly. She also considers that the GDPR does not preclude the directive: the former governs lawful and transparent processing, the latter the accuracy of commercial claims, and both apply cumulatively. Nor does she see a restriction on the freedom to conduct a business, as companies may still offer services in exchange for data, just without calling them free. For these practices, there is no need to show that the average consumer was actually misled.
The Opinion is not binding. The judges are now deliberating and judgment will follow at a later date.
Our view at CEA Digital Law
At the Euro-American Committee of Digital Law - CEA Digital Law, we welcome a proposal that brings consumer law and data protection into line. If the Court follows it, transparency about what a service « costs » will no longer depend on whether a price is charged in euros.
In practice, platforms would need to review their sign-up messaging and consider clearer wording, such as stating that the service is funded by data and advertising. For Latin America and the Caribbean, where many countries are debating or applying data and consumer laws, the case offers a useful lesson: combine both frameworks so that neither displaces the other. In Africa, where the digital economy is growing fast and data protection frameworks are consolidating, data as consideration will be just as relevant.
Open questions remain: how the exception for strictly necessary processing will work, and how this logic will extend to other « free » services such as apps or search engines. Following the judgment closely, and developing good-practice guidance on user information, will be key.
Sources
CEA Digital Law
Lettre d’information
Événements, actualités et analyses sur le droit numérique, dans votre boîte de réception. Seulement quand il y a quelque chose à dire.
Adhésion
Rejoignez l’Euro-American Committee of Digital Law - CEA Digital Law
Une communauté internationale qui se distingue par l’excellence professionnelle de ses membres. Être membre n’entraîne aucune cotisation ni aucun frais : ce qui nous unit, c’est la recherche et les objectifs d’une organisation internationale à but non lucratif.
Publiez avec nous
Écrivez dans Tribuna Atlántica
Tribuna Atlántica. Pensamiento Contemporáneo, la publication internationale de CEA Digital Law, ouvre ses pages à celles et ceux qui apportent connaissances, expérience professionnelle, recherche ou réflexion pour comprendre notre époque. Elle recherche un regard personnel, fondé sur la rigueur et de bonnes sources, issu de disciplines et de territoires divers.




