CNIL fines a life insurer €5 million over plaintext passwords

CNIL fines a life insurer €5 million over plaintext passwords

In brief

  • On 12 November 2026 the CNIL's restricted committee adopted deliberation SAN-2026-016, published on Légifrance on 18 November, imposing a €5 million fine.
  • It found breaches of Articles 32 and 5(1)(e) GDPR: plaintext passwords, shared accounts and excessive retention.
  • The decision can be appealed to the Conseil d'État, and the CNIL chose not to name the company.

France’s data protection authority, the Commission nationale de l’informatique et des libertés (CNIL), has fined a life insurer €5 million for failing to protect its customers’ data properly. Deliberation SAN-2026-016 of 12 November 2026 was published on Légifrance on 18 November and is a clear reminder that basic security measures remain both mandatory and sanctionable.

What happened

The CNIL received an alert on 27 December 2023 about how passwords and customer-account data were stored, and carried out an on-site inspection on 14 May 2024. Its restricted committee found that nearly 1.8 million customer passwords were stored in plaintext, with no hashing at all, and that 730,289 of them also appeared in plaintext in a connection-log table. After the inspection the company first adopted an obsolete, unsalted hash function; only on 25 April 2026 did it move to a state-of-the-art solution (Argon2 with a salt).

The deliberation also records that access to the database covering about 1.3 million clients with active life-insurance contracts used a generic account shared by eight people, and that the administrator password for a data-viewing tool was shared as well. Without individual accounts there is no traceability and no effective management of access rights.

Excessive retention and the amount of the fine

On retention (Article 5(1)(e) GDPR), the CNIL found contact-form messages, with attachments and bank details, held in the live database since November 2010. The connection log contained credentials up to 21 years old, even though the company’s own policy set one year, and passwords of 8,628 customers kept since July 2019.

It is worth noting what the CNIL did not uphold: the rapporteur dropped the complaints about health data and about the strength of customer passwords. No security incident was established either; the authority stresses that the vulnerability exists whether or not anyone exploited it.

The rapporteur first proposed €9 million and later €7 million. The restricted committee set €5 million, calculated on the group’s turnover as an « undertaking » in the competition-law sense (recital 150 GDPR and Court of Justice case law), using gross written premiums as the reference in the insurance sector. It issued no compliance order because everything had been corrected during the procedure, but held that the breaches remained established « for the past ». It ordered publication without naming the company. An appeal to the Conseil d’État is possible within two months of notification.

Our view at CEA Digital Law

This decision offers useful lessons for the Euro-American Committee of Digital Law - CEA Digital Law and for readers in Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean, and Africa:

  • Basic security is a measurable standard. The CNIL relies on public guidance (ANSSI, its own 2022 recommendation) to define what is « appropriate » under Article 32. Authorities elsewhere can do likewise with clear technical guidance, which also helps controllers.
  • Prompt correction mitigates but does not erase. The company’s speed avoided an injunction, not the fine. Every corrective step should be documented with dates and evidence.
  • A retention policy only counts if it is enforced. Setting periods is not enough: purges must actually run, including on technical logs, where credentials and personal data tend to hide.
  • Named user accounts and regular access reviews belong on every checklist, especially in insurance, banking and health.
  • Open question: using the group’s turnover as the basis will remain debated before the administrative courts. It matters to anyone applying GDPR-inspired regimes with turnover-based penalties.

Our practical advice to insurers and other controllers: audit password storage, remove credentials from logs, replace shared accounts and check that purges work, before an inspection does it for you.

Sources

CEA Digital Law

Lettre d’information

Événements, actualités et analyses sur le droit numérique, dans votre boîte de réception. Seulement quand il y a quelque chose à dire.