Mexico: Supreme Court declines Telcel’s appeal over IFT competition fine

Mexico: Supreme Court declines Telcel’s appeal over IFT competition fine

In brief

  • On 18 November 2026, the plenary of Mexico's Suprema Corte de Justicia de la Nación rejected, by six votes to three, a request to take over the Telcel case.
  • The file returns to the Segundo Tribunal Colegiado de Circuito en Materia Administrativa, Especializado en Competencia Económica, Radiodifusión y Telecomunicaciones.
  • The fine of 90,659,701.72 pesos was imposed by the IFT in 2024 for a relative monopolistic practice.

On 18 November 2026, Mexico’s Suprema Corte de Justicia de la Nación (SCJN) decided not to take over the litigation on the fine that the Instituto Federal de Telecomunicaciones (IFT) imposed on Telcel in 2024. The decision is procedural, but it keeps open one of the sector’s most significant competition sanctions in Mexico.

What the Court decided

According to La Jornada, the plenary rejected by six votes to three the proposal of its president, Hugo Aguilar Ortiz, to reassume jurisdiction. Justices Yasmín Esquivel Mossa and Lenia Batres Guadarrama voted with him. As Xataka México reports, the request was listed as reasunción de competencia 180/2026.

The file goes back to the Segundo Tribunal Colegiado de Circuito en Materia Administrativa, Especializado en Competencia Económica, Radiodifusión y Telecomunicaciones (a specialised appeals court based in Mexico City). It must decide amparo en revisión 268/2025, concerning the federal court judgment that denied Telcel’s amparo.

Where the sanction came from

The case began with a complaint by AT&T filed on 21 December 2020. The IFT opened an investigation on 26 January 2021 and examined the relationship between Telcel and Grupo Bodesa. According to the decision, discounts and incentives for the distributor were conditional on it ceasing to sell SIM bundles and top-ups from rival operators.

The IFT plenary unanimously approved the sanction on 4 September 2024 and announced it on 11 September. It set a fine of 90,659,701.72 pesos on Radiomóvil Dipsa (Telcel) and ordered it to stop the relative monopolistic practice. América Móvil denied the conduct and said it would use the defences available to it.

What remains to be decided

According to La Jornada, Telcel questions whether articles 55 and 80 of the Ley Federal de Competencia Económica guarantee the right of defence and due process. That constitutional question is what the specialised court will now examine. The fine remains in dispute and there is no final ruling on the merits.

Our view at CEA Digital Law

At the Euro-American Committee of Digital Law - CEA Digital Law, we draw three lessons from this case, without prejudging the outcome.

First, the value of specialised courts. Sending the amparo to a body with expertise in competition and telecommunications supports technically sound and consistent decisions, which is useful for other countries in Latin America and the Caribbean and in Africa that are still building that judicial specialisation.

Second, exclusivity arrangements in distribution are a shared concern for competition authorities in Europe and across the region. European experience with conditional incentives shows the importance of defining the relevant market clearly and proving effects on rivals, and the Mexican case already distinguishes between the regional scope of SIM handsets and the national scope of top-ups.

Third, due process guarantees in regulators’ sanctioning procedures are key to legal certainty. A clear answer from the court on the challenged articles would be a valuable reference for operators, regulators and consumers. We will follow the matter with interest.

Sources

CEA Digital Law

Lettre d’information

Événements, actualités et analyses sur le droit numérique, dans votre boîte de réception. Seulement quand il y a quelque chose à dire.

Adhésion

Rejoignez l’Euro-American Committee of Digital Law - CEA Digital Law

Une communauté internationale qui se distingue par l’excellence professionnelle de ses membres. Être membre n’entraîne aucune cotisation ni aucun frais : ce qui nous unit, c’est la recherche et les objectifs d’une organisation internationale à but non lucratif.

Demander à nous rejoindre

Publiez avec nous

Écrivez dans Tribuna Atlántica

Tribuna Atlántica. Pensamiento Contemporáneo, la publication internationale de CEA Digital Law, ouvre ses pages à celles et ceux qui apportent connaissances, expérience professionnelle, recherche ou réflexion pour comprendre notre époque. Elle recherche un regard personnel, fondé sur la rigueur et de bonnes sources, issu de disciplines et de territoires divers.

Publier dans Tribuna