Colombia: Tribunal backs the SIC against Google on personal data

Colombia: Tribunal backs the SIC against Google on personal data

In brief

  • In Judgment 286 of 5 November 2026, the Tribunal Administrativo de Cundinamarca rejected at first instance Google LLC's challenge to SIC orders issued in 2020 and 2021.
  • According to the reporting, foreign companies must comply with Colombian law when they collect data from users located in Colombia, wherever they are established.
  • The ruling is a first-instance decision: its progress, and the lessons for other jurisdictions, deserve attention.

The Tribunal Administrativo de Cundinamarca has sided with the Superintendencia de Industria y Comercio (SIC), Colombia’s data protection authority, in its dispute with Google LLC over personal data processing. It matters because it tackles a question central to the whole region: must global platforms comply with local law when they collect data from people located in the country?

What the Tribunal decided

According to Asuntos Legales, Judgment 286 of 5 November 2026 rejected, at first instance, the claim for annulment and restoration of rights that Google LLC filed in April 2022. The company sought to overturn orders the SIC issued to it between 2020 and 2021.

Google argued that Colombian rules did not apply to it, as it is incorporated in the United States and stores and processes information outside Colombia. The Tribunal disagreed: it held that foreign companies must also respect Colombian law when they collect personal data from users located in Colombian territory, wherever they are domiciled.

Background to the dispute

The case began in 2019, when the SIC opened an ex officio investigation prompted by information about a United States Federal Trade Commission action concerning children’s data on YouTube. In September 2020, the SIC found that Google LLC used cookies to collect personal data from users in Colombia and ordered it to bring its practices into line with Law 1581 of 2012.

The SIC stated that data relating to some 39 million adults and 1.84 million minors in Colombia was being processed. It also held that 52.63% of the requirements assessed in the company’s data policy did not meet national rules. Among other orders, it required proof of prior, express and informed authorisation from the legal representatives of minors whose data had been processed after Law 1581 came into force.

Scope and limits of the ruling

This is a first-instance judgment. It does not necessarily close the debate, and what happens next will depend on any appeals. Even so, it sends a clear signal on territorial reach: what counts is where the people whose data is collected are located, not where servers sit or where the company is based.

Our view at CEA Digital Law

This approach echoes the extraterritorial reach of the European General Data Protection Regulation, which also rests on the location of the individuals concerned. For Latin America and the Caribbean, and for African countries building up their data protection authorities, the case is a useful reference: a well-drafted data law can protect residents against global operators even without a local establishment.

We suggest three lines of work. First, authorities should document the use of tools such as cookies with technical rigour, as the SIC did by quantifying the people affected. Second, standards on children’s data should be strengthened, since consent from legal representatives is the most sensitive point. Third, regional authorities should step up cooperation, so that territorial enforcement criteria are consistent and give legal certainty to both data subjects and companies.

Open questions remain: how compliance with the orders will be verified in practice, what a second-instance court may say, and how this doctrine will fit with international data flows. The Euro-American Committee of Digital Law - CEA Digital Law will keep following the matter.

Sources

CEA Digital Law

Boletim

Eventos, notícias e análises sobre direito digital, no seu e-mail. Só quando houver novidades.

Adesão

Faça parte do Comitê Euro-Americano de Direito Digital - CEA Digital Law

Uma comunidade internacional que se destaca pela excelência profissional dos seus membros. Ser membro não tem quotas nem custos de qualquer tipo: une-nos a investigação e os fins de uma organização internacional sem fins lucrativos.

Solicite sua adesão

Publique conosco

Escreva na Tribuna Atlántica

A Tribuna Atlántica. Pensamiento Contemporáneo, a publicação internacional do CEA Digital Law, abre suas páginas a quem contribua com conhecimento, experiência profissional, pesquisa ou reflexão para compreender o nosso tempo. Busca um olhar próprio, sustentado com rigor e boas fontes, a partir de diferentes disciplinas e territórios.

Publique na Tribuna