In brief
- In Austro-Mechana (C-579/24), the CJEU rules that the authorisation online content-sharing service providers must obtain also covers acts of reproduction.
- The same reasoning applies to users who upload content, where Article 17(2) extends the platform's authorisation to them.
- The Court avoids a dual regime for platforms and strengthens legal certainty.
In the days before 14 November 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled that the authorisation required by Article 17(1) of the DSM Directive from platforms hosting user-uploaded content covers not only communication to the public but also reproduction. The ruling came in Austro-Mechana, C-579/24, and follows the Opinion of Advocate General Emiliou.
The question
Article 17(1) requires online content-sharing service providers (OCSSPs) to obtain authorisation from rightholders to communicate or make available works to the public. Before doing so, however, these providers store the content uploaded by users. The Austrian Federal Administrative Court asked whether that preliminary step needs a separate authorisation.
The Court’s reasoning
As reported by The IPKat (the judgment was not yet available in English), the CJEU starts from the broad notion of reproduction in Article 2 of the InfoSoc Directive (2001/29/EC) and concludes that storing protected content on a platform’s server is an act of reproduction. It adds that this reading is consistent with the WIPO Copyright Treaty and Article 9 of the Berne Convention.
The Court also rules out the temporary-copies exception in Article 5(1) InfoSoc: its conditions are cumulative, and the temporary character is not met here. It accepts that Article 17(1) is ambiguously worded, but prefers the reading that avoids two separate regimes for platforms: InfoSoc plus the Digital Services Act (Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, with its hosting safe harbour) on one side, and the DSM Directive on the other.
Effect on users
The same approach applies to Article 17(2). Where the platform’s authorisation extends to users (those not acting on a commercial basis or not generating significant revenues), it also covers the reproductions they make when uploading, and not only the Article 3 InfoSoc acts.
Our view at CEA Digital Law
At the Euro-American Committee of Digital Law - CEA Digital Law, we welcome a ruling that puts practical coherence first. For platforms, it lowers the risk of a licence being hollowed out because it does not mention reproduction. For rightholders and collecting societies, it clarifies the minimum any agreement must cover, although nothing prevents a broader scope being negotiated, as the commentator notes.
Open questions remain: how this will affect licences already signed, how the commercial-activity threshold for users will be applied, and what role remuneration mechanisms will play. For Latin America and the Caribbean and for Africa, where several countries are reviewing copyright rules on platforms, the judgment offers a useful lesson: a single framework for platform liability, rather than one split across rights, supports legal certainty and eases negotiation. We suggest that lawmakers drawing on Article 17 specify from the outset the scope of authorisation over all the exclusive rights involved.
Sources
- The IPKat: CJEU follows AG Opinion and rules that the authorization under Article 17(1) of the DSM Directive also covers acts of reproduction
- TJUE, asunto C-579/24 Austro-Mechana (Infocuria)
- Directiva (UE) 2019/790 (DSM), EUR-Lex
CEA Digital Law
النشرة
فعاليات وأخبار وتحليلات في القانون الرقمي تصلك على بريدك، ولا نراسلك إلا حين يكون لدينا جديد.




